Former financial advisor John Jay Kersey, previously based in Cincinnati, Ohio, is the subject of serious allegations involving the misappropriation of client funds and the creation of false account documents. Regulatory records indicate that he has been barred from the securities industry following claims that he accepted personal checks from clients for investments that never materialized on the firm’s books. With alleged damages exceeding $12 million, many investors are now seeking answers about how this misconduct went undetected.
If you have suffered significant investment losses working with Jay Kersey or Northwestern Mutual, don’t hesitate to reach out to Meyer Wilson Werning today. Our attorneys are experienced in securities fraud cases and will help to guide you through the process with a free and confidential consultation to determine whether your losses are the result of actionable misconduct.
What Are the Allegations Against John Jay Kersey?
The allegations against John Jay Kersey (CRD#: 1480524) describe a troubling pattern of deception and mishandling of client assets. According to regulatory disclosures, Kersey was permitted to resign from Northwestern Mutual Investment Services, LLC while under internal investigation. The firm reported that he was being investigated for allegedly taking money from a client and creating false account documents that overstated the value of their investments.
Notably, reports indicate that Kersey admitted to depositing customer funds into an account away from the firm—a severe violation of securities regulations known as “selling away” or misappropriation.
Key details regarding his regulatory history include:
-
Barred by FINRA: On November 10, 2023, the Financial Industry Regulatory Authority (FINRA) barred Kersey from the securities industry after he failed to respond to requests for information regarding the investigation.
-
Customer Complaints: His record displays 12 customer complaints.
-
Total Alleged Damages: The disputes involve claimed damages totaling more than $12 million.
We Have Recovered Over
$350 Million for Our Clients Nationwide.
How Did the Alleged Misconduct Occur?
The complaints against Jay Kersey suggest that he exploited the trust of his clients in Cincinnati and beyond. In several instances, investors claim they wrote personal checks directly to Kersey, believing the funds were being deposited into their investment accounts.
Later, these clients reportedly discovered that Northwestern Mutual had no record of these transactions. To conceal the missing funds, it is alleged that Kersey provided false account documents that made it appear as though the investments were performing well, when in reality, the values were overstated or the funds were missing entirely.
Common allegations in these disputes include:
-
Misappropriation of funds: Using client money for unauthorized purposes.
-
Misrepresentation: Providing false information about investment performance or account status.
-
Unsuitable investment recommendations: Advice that did not align with the client’s financial situation or goals.
Can Northwestern Mutual Be Held Liable?
Brokerage firms like Northwestern Mutual have a legal obligation to reasonably supervise their financial advisors. This duty to supervise is a cornerstone of investor protection laws. Firms are required to have systems in place to detect and prevent misconduct, such as reviewing correspondence, monitoring deposits, and ensuring that advisors are not engaging in unapproved outside business activities.
If a firm fails to uphold these standards, it may be held liable for the resulting investor losses. Victims of Jay Kersey may be able to file a claim against the brokerage firm for failure to supervise or negligence, seeking recovery of their lost funds.
Our lawyers are nationwide leaders in investment fraud cases.
How Meyer Wilson Werning Helps Victims of John Jay Kersey
The allegations of misappropriation and falsified documents against John Jay Kersey highlight the devastating impact of broker misconduct. When a financial advisor steps outside the bounds of the law, the brokerage firm charged with supervising them must be held accountable for failing to protect clients.
If you or someone you know has been impacted by a securities or investment scam, the experienced attorneys at Meyer Wilson Werning are here to help. With more than 20 years in the industry and over $350 million recovered for our clients, our focus on investment fraud and securities litigation has helped many investors recover their losses. Contact us today for a free consultation to discuss your case and learn how we can assist you in protecting your financial interests.
We Are The firm other lawyers
call for support.
Frequently Asked Questions
What did John Jay Kersey allegedly do to client funds?
John Jay Kersey is accused of accepting personal checks from clients and depositing the funds into an account away from Northwestern Mutual. He allegedly created false documents to hide this activity and overstate account values.
Is Jay Kersey still working as a financial advisor?
No. On November 10, 2023, FINRA barred Jay Kersey from the securities industry. He is no longer licensed to act as a broker or financial advisor.
Can I sue Northwestern Mutual for my losses?
Yes, it is possible to pursue a claim against Northwestern Mutual for failure to supervise. Even though the advisor has been barred, the firm may be responsible for failing to detect and prevent the misconduct.
How much does it cost to hire a lawyer for a FINRA claim?
Firms like ours typically operate on a contingency fee basis. This means there are no hourly billing rates or upfront costs for our services; legal fees are only collected as a percentage of the money recovered.
Recovering Losses Caused by Investment Misconduct.
